Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It's certainly a popular poem, but I don't see any great evidence it has ever reflected American values.


Not even in that only 3% of the US population is Native American, and the rest are therefore descended from or are themselves immigrants?


As time goes on, the rejection of the idea of US-born people being "natives" in the sense that the rest of the world uses the term, simply because we have another term, "Native Americans" (which, as you will notice, is a proper noun), with a different meaning, is getting more and more dishonest. Yes, language is funny. Yes, the origins of nations are tragic if you go back far enough, and future citizens inherit the distributed weight of that guilt (but not the responsibility). But now, we have 300 million living people whose practical reality we would like discuss, and on that topic you are free and encouraged to disagree with anybody.


All the more reason to avoid the fate of the Native Americans.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: