Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The total sum of all natural resources has yet to be discovered. We were supposed to hit peak oil in what, the 1990's? Trees are on a dramatic decline, but they still exist. No one can correctly or meaningfully count the amount of natural resources left in total existence. And when there's scarcity, another solution tends to emerge as substitute.

As such, as parent stated, it's not a zero sum game. Zero sum assumes you can define the end state.

That being said, whether or not it's zero-sum is meaningless, and I don't take issue with arguing against the parent. Ultimately, the wealth-gap is widening to detrimental effect. The middle class is being divided into haves and have nots.

Whether you believe this is a problem, that's probably another type of discussion.



> We were supposed to hit peak oil in what, the 1990's?

Originally the late 60's, actually, according to Wikipedia.

The failure of Malthusian catastrophes to occur despite centuries of prediction hasn't dampened enthusiasm for predicting them to occur in the near future.


The failure of Malthusian catastrophes is largely down to population growth stagnating, not because infinite growth was ever sustainable.


Malthusian catastrophe occurred in Bangladesh, India and Pakistan.


> And when there's scarcity, another solution tends to emerge as substitute.

then why do we so much conservation and create all sorts of laws around it ?




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: