> The developer basically has to rewrite them and turn them into different apps to make them work in Wayland. Is that good or bad? Maybe if you hate a certain type of app it's good
Just to make the record straight, it's not about "hating" anybody or anything. And I really don't see the need to appeal to emotions here.
It is about acknowledging that this way of doing things might, in retrospect, have been a bad idea all along and represents a technical dead-end. Departing from it, given the chance, is for the benefit of all in the long run (tech doesn't like carrying old bags around forever, and I suspect that your laptop don't hold a CD-ROM drive for similar reasons).
> if something doesn't hurt anyone then you should probably be allowed to do it
It would cost the Wayland compositors developers extra effort to maintain this capability for decades to come, it's not free. Moreover, those apps would still be broken by design (not in a position to do as good a job at positioning their windows as the compositors would do), so the compositors developers would, as a second order of annoyance, probably see their issue trackers filling-up with user complaints that are outside of their scope/power to address.
> this is the open source world
And the great news here is that those entrenched apps who refuse to adopt more modern UX paradigms (for the detriment of their old and new users alike, if I might say) will still be able to run through XWayland virtually forever.
Just to make the record straight, it's not about "hating" anybody or anything. And I really don't see the need to appeal to emotions here. It is about acknowledging that this way of doing things might, in retrospect, have been a bad idea all along and represents a technical dead-end. Departing from it, given the chance, is for the benefit of all in the long run (tech doesn't like carrying old bags around forever, and I suspect that your laptop don't hold a CD-ROM drive for similar reasons).
> if something doesn't hurt anyone then you should probably be allowed to do it
It would cost the Wayland compositors developers extra effort to maintain this capability for decades to come, it's not free. Moreover, those apps would still be broken by design (not in a position to do as good a job at positioning their windows as the compositors would do), so the compositors developers would, as a second order of annoyance, probably see their issue trackers filling-up with user complaints that are outside of their scope/power to address.
> this is the open source world
And the great news here is that those entrenched apps who refuse to adopt more modern UX paradigms (for the detriment of their old and new users alike, if I might say) will still be able to run through XWayland virtually forever.