> Someone who makes 10 million dollars (or 100 million, or...) a year pays the exact same social security tax as someone who makes $176,100.
Very few people earn that kind of money as taxable _income_. More people earn that kind of money as unrealized _capital gains_. Social security is paid for with a payroll tax and what amounts to an income tax. Once you're earning several times the cap you stop caring about it. If you earn 5x or 10x the cap then you will probably not be counting on social security, so there's no us-vs-them dynamic likely there. The problem is that to make this make a big different you'll have to hit hard those who earn only 1.5x or 2x the cap, and that's how you'd get an us-vs-them dynamic.
Instead you can increase the retirement age, increase the cap, increase the tax rates, lower the COLAs, etc., and that's what we've seen so far.
Very few people make a lot of money, it those who do make a shockingly large amount of it.
There’s two drivers to the actual problem here… one is that wage growth slowed a lot since wage indexing and the yield on those taxes is lower in real terms. People who are making more make a lot more, and frankly that’s a well that needs to be tapped.
The other is less popular… but we’re in wind down of nearly 25 years of conflict. The events of 9/11 were engineered to and succeeded in created the same type of economic attrition the US ultimately inflicted on the Soviets.
We’re at a tipping point… our social insurance is approaching entirely avoidable cash flow insolvency. 25 years of war means that the military is worn out and needs trillions of investment to maintain parity. Ignoring the problems our strategies created brought us with a reactionary buffoon destroying the government and a fairly dim decade ahead.
Very few people earn that kind of money as taxable _income_. More people earn that kind of money as unrealized _capital gains_. Social security is paid for with a payroll tax and what amounts to an income tax. Once you're earning several times the cap you stop caring about it. If you earn 5x or 10x the cap then you will probably not be counting on social security, so there's no us-vs-them dynamic likely there. The problem is that to make this make a big different you'll have to hit hard those who earn only 1.5x or 2x the cap, and that's how you'd get an us-vs-them dynamic.
Instead you can increase the retirement age, increase the cap, increase the tax rates, lower the COLAs, etc., and that's what we've seen so far.