Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I don't think it is reading pictures from the brain at all. The way I understand it, it can only recognised pictures the computer has learned before.

As an analogy, imagine your eye lid twitches every time somebody mentions George Bush. The computer would then learn that when your eye lid twitches, you are thinking about George Bush. Not very exciting imo.

I think there was an experiment with a cat where they actually generated an image from what fell on the cat's retina. THAT was scary to me.




The article states that the actual images shown during the second phase were different than the "training" images that the computer showed to subject and used to "learn".


Hm, must have missed that. So they train on a letter "A" and then they can recognise a "B"?


I think they trained on a bunch of random patterns, and can recognize basically anything of approximately the same resolution.


I think there was an experiment with a cat where they actually generated an image from what fell on the cat's retina.

The only study I've ever seen on this has been based on simply grabbing the image off the reflection of the eye. I can't imagine this actually involved hooking up a cat's visual cortex to some sort of interface, the sheer processing power required for that sort of visual information processing is unfathomable.

If not, link me!


They did do that, it was in Scientific American in an article about the eyes. They they did not take it from the visual cortex though, but rather from neurons coming from the retina.

The retina has various layers and they took a look at what each layer does.


They put smashed bananas into the cats' brains to record the signals.

(It's less ridiculous than it sounds: Bananas contain a certain enzyme that helps to capture the neurons signals. The porridge they put around the sensors in the cats' brains contained many more things besides the bananas. My fiancee was studying that stuff in university.)


Just googled this: http://www.arthurmag.com/magpie/?p=395 don't know if it is the same experiment I read about, and no time for more googling ;-)


That's the one. They were recording in the lateral geniculate nucleus, however (ie more similar to the representation coming straight off the retina).

More here: http://www.stanley.bme.gatech.edu/research_topics_vision.htm...




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: