It wasn't supposed to be that way. Even the Reddiquette page told people not to downvote simply because they disagree. But nobody reads Reddiquette, and these days most redditors think disagreement is the purpose of downvotes.
That being said, you'd have to be naive to think downvoting for disagreement doesn't happen on HN.
> post throttling
This is only a thing for new accounts as an anti-spam measure.
> over zealous moderators banning people for wrongthink
I think it's wrong to blame reddit for this. This will be a problem on ANY site that allows users to create their own communities within it.
It wasn't supposed to be that way. Even the Reddiquette page told people not to downvote simply because they disagree. But nobody reads Reddiquette, and these days most redditors think disagreement is the purpose of downvotes.
That being said, you'd have to be naive to think downvoting for disagreement doesn't happen on HN.
> post throttling
This is only a thing for new accounts as an anti-spam measure.
> over zealous moderators banning people for wrongthink
I think it's wrong to blame reddit for this. This will be a problem on ANY site that allows users to create their own communities within it.