Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> And it makes the news and... so what.

What do you mean? They got what they wanted, more or less. They're a group of people organized around an idea, figured they weren't getting attention, so they went to look for a way to get some. That's all there is to it.

I think you're expecting some sort of special significance here. No, it's not complicated or even special.




Getting attention doesn't save the planet. Giving up saving the planet for the goal of getting attention is fundamentally nihilistic.


> Getting attention doesn't save the planet

On its own it doesn't. If you need to recruit people to your cause though you need people to know you exist and there's somewhere they can join.

> Giving up saving the planet for the goal of getting attention is fundamentally nihilistic.

Er, how are they giving up?

What they're doing is regularly shouting "Save the planet!" at people. Only this time they picked a weirder way to do it, because nobody was paying attention to the more normal ways they had to say it.


"Propaganda of the deed" is as likely to make people think climate change protestors are crazy and just make them close their earflaps as it is to motivate more people to take desperate nihilistic actions. This spectacle at best convinces people to tune out.

It's got to me more like this.

You have to tell the ESG people that what matters about Exxon Mobil is (1) they have to stop fact investing in producing oil that other people burn, (2) it wouldn't matter if they became a "net zero" company by pumping CO₂ from their oil refineries in the ground and using synthetic fuels in their trucks, (3) it doesn't matter how many women they get on the board.

People who are concerned about climate change in the US should be concerned about institutional reform in the Democratic party. Namely, we shouldn't be in situations like

https://www.inquirer.com/politics/election/senate-debate-pen...

where a lunatic that could be beaten by a ham sandwich could win because the Democrats don't think that Pennsylvania deserves a senator who can verbally communicate effectively. (e.g. out of everybody in the state Philadelphia could get somebody in the top 1% of verbal communication skills as a Senator, why do they have to get somebody who is disabled?)


I haven't the faintest idea of what you're talking about.

Again, I think you're under the impression that this particular event was supposed to be in some way Meaningful. Part of some grand strategy or a big movement or something. I'm telling you it's not.

As far as I can tell, https://juststopoil.org came into existence around February this year. They're just a small, new group formed around opposition to Big Oil that's trying to make some noise. This paintings thing is attempt #25, and it just happens to be weird enough to make the news, but not fundamentally different to the 24 that came before it.

In fact they tried previously gluing themselves to microphone at a news agency:

https://juststopoil.org/2022/04/03/just-stop-oil-supporter-g...

I see no indication that this is part of some grand strategy from the Democrats or something. No, it's just a small group doing a weird thing and getting news coverage because weird thing is weird.

Edit: And in fact, Just Stop Oil is UK based, so they have nothing to do with the US Democrats or Pennsylvania.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: