Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

My anecdata...

I started trading on RH in 2019. They make investing simple and approachable for someone who like me who knew the basics and just wanted to play around a bit with some spare cash.

But after a couple years when I want to start taking it more seriously, their platform has failed to grow and improve. In the three years I've used them, I can't think of a single new feature they added that I use. Meanwhile, there are plenty of things I'd like. For example, it's beyond ridiculous that price graphs don't have their axes labeled. When selling stock, it's always FIFO, so I can't choose which lots to sell to optimize tax liabilities.

The problem is that I have a hard time leaving because their margin rates (~3%) are so damn good compared to the major players (8% or higher).




Interactive Brokers have always had the best margin rates: https://www.interactivebrokers.com/en/trading/margin-rates.p...

Current max is 1.83% but the more you borrow it asymptotically approaches 1%. (subject to change, same as RH)


IB has very conservative risk management wrt margin and there is no margin call. If the market moves against you, they will liquidate you rapidly. Something to keep in mind when considering your LTV. Their margin rates are good, but there’s a reason they’re good.


I made an account 5 months ago and i could not make margin work on IRB and customer was unressponsive. Acated into RH and got it instantly.

Brokers are as behind compared to robinhood as car manufacturers are with RH.

Its just not a great business.


Good margin rates will be difficult to find in a rising interest rate environment. You can get lower rates from traditional brokers if you have a substantial net worth btw ($1MM+ AUM).


They’re a frontend to Citadel to “unlock” value for the investors.

It was never meant to compete with real investing tools but instigate transaction fees and accumulate retail behavior data for the market makers


RH is for trading (gambling, like you were doing) not investing.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: