Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Does this basically force people to have a Canadian bank account to survive?



Not strictly (as the sibling comment says), but also, in practice it doesn’t matter, as there are effectively no “unbanked” Canadians the way there are “unbanked” Americans.

From https://www.canada.ca/en/financial-consumer-agency/services/... :

> In Canada, you have the right to open a bank account at a bank or a federally regulated credit union as long as you show proper identification.

> You can open an account even if you: don’t have a job; don’t have money to put in the account right away; or have been bankrupt.

But that requirement to show identification is important. What it means in practice is that everyone who resides in Canada except illegal immigrants can open a Canadian bank account.

And the fact that so many crucial government services assume that you have a Canadian bank account (not just for SSO, but also because they assume things like the ability to do direct deposit for tax refunds, welfare/unemployment, etc.), means that it’s really hard to be an illegal immigrant in Canada. Which is probably one reason among many that people generally aren’t interested in trying. (Other reasons: we don’t have any land borders except with the US, and it’s easier to be an illegal immigrant in the US, so why not just stop there? And: the Canada Border Services Agency is terrifying to interact with, even for Canadian citizens.)


I don't know about Canada specifically, but generally there are situations where one can be waiting for a residence permit or waiting to be fully registered as a resident, etc. It can take several months in some western European countries despite the same laws that nobody can be denied a bank account. This can create a lot of inconvenience for legal residents that recently immigrated since some of those countries also have systems that use banks for ID.


There are ways around this and I have seldom seen it used outside of government services, so not really.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: