Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

It's an important tool for repressing criminals and minorities.



You don't have to be a criminal or a minority to be affected. There have been lots of reports of old, white men being hit by this for having the audacity to travel around with >$10k in cash.

Steve Lehto's YouTube channel covers these stories a lot.


Also in padding the budgets of the law enforcement agencies!


I too can make claims without any evidence.


The article we’re all commenting on is really good evidence. But here’s more:

> A 1993 investigation by The Orlando Sentinel revealed that nine of every 10 motorists who were stopped and stripped of their cash by police in Volusia County, Florida, were either black or Hispanic, and three out of four were never charged with a crime. In Philadelphia, where nearly 300 houses are seized annually, African Americans make up 44% of the population but 63% of house seizures and 71% of cash forfeitures unaccompanied by a conviction. Forfeiture is also most likely to affect economically disadvantaged communities: One study found that areas with high income inequality were targeted for civil forfeiture operations, likely because these police departments have limited funding and are inclined to use forfeiture to secure needed revenue.

source: https://www.splcenter.org/20171030/civil-asset-forfeiture-un...


Have the race numbers been regressed against wealth/income? I'd reckon it's mostly just poor discrimination (i.e. people who can't afford a lawyer) rather than straight racism.


“Indirect” racism is also racism. There may be a semantic difference, but no practical difference to the victims.


I disagree. Correct identification of root cause guides effective solutions. If you solve "indirect racism" just for one race, the rest of poor people are still screwed. If you solve the original cause (poverty), everyone is better off.


Nirvana fallacy: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nirvana_fallacy

While it would be great if we could Solve Poverty (TM), I think reducing legalized theft of poor people’s assets would be a great first step.

Nobody in this thread was arguing that we should solve it only for some races, rather that it does seem to affect them more often.


I was more referring to the "criminals" part


no its not.


Yeah, whyties always get refund from police. After showing their race ID and prooving their aryan purity!




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: