Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The motte:

- "I'm not calling anyone dumb."

- "I'm just alluding to the famous quote"

The bailey:

- "A lot of [Them] are making bank [and are] terrified of their skill set being made obsolete."

- "They have no idea what it means to use a dedicated server."

- "[They believe] bare-metal means “server room here in the office”"

FWIW, it definitely plays great: we all love to believe everyone who disagrees with us is ignorant, usually I'd upvote something like this and downvote a reply like mine, but this was so bad it hit an internal tripwire of "This is literally just a bunch of comments about They, where They is all the other comments."

You can easily play it off with "I didn't call other commenters DUMB, I just said they don't know a server is just a computer and they don't have to be in your office or in Amazon's data center to serve things!"

To riff on the famous quote you "just meant to allude to": "It is difficult to get an [interlocutor] to understand something [about their argumentation] when [they're playing to the crowd and being applauded]" I hope reading that gives you a sense of how strong of a contribution it is to discussion, as well as how well-founded it is, as well as what it implies.





You are the one who called them "dumb". You are the one making the judgement call here.

And I stand by what I said: lots of people don't have experience with non-AWS setups and are going around repeating AWS salespeople cliches.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: